The Cost and Benefits of Asphalt Pavement vs. Concrete: A Comprehensive Comparison

Selecting the most suitable pavement material for your residential or commercial project can be a challenging decision. Among the various options available, asphalt and concrete are the most common choices, each offering a unique set of advantages and drawbacks. Understanding the pricing, performance, and maintenance costs of both pavement types is crucial in determining the most appropriate solution for your particular situation.

In this detailed blog post, we will compare the costs and benefits of asphalt and concrete pavement in areas such as durability, ease of installation, maintenance, aesthetics, and environmental impact. This comprehensive comparison will provide you with the necessary knowledge to make an informed decision on the best material for your residential or commercial paving project. Furthermore, we will emphasize how partnering with an experienced paving contractor like Economy Asphalt can provide tailored advice and expert services to ensure a successful, cost-effective, and high-quality paving outcome.

Economy Asphalt is Omaha’s premier asphalt company, with the expertise and commitment to client satisfaction required to handle any residential or commercial paving project. Our team of professionals are available to provide expert guidance on material choices, ensuring that you find the perfect balance between cost and performance to meet your unique needs. Join us as we delve into the world of asphalt and concrete pavements to help simplify your decision-making process and lead you towards a successful and cost-effective paving solution.

Environmental Impacts

When choosing between asphalt and concrete paving materials for your project, considering their respective environmental impacts can be crucial in making a more sustainable decision.

1. Asphalt environmental impact: Asphalt is a recyclable material, with the majority of reclaimed asphalt being reused in new pavement projects. Additionally, asphalt pavement typically allows for faster drainage, helping reduce potential flooding and runoff.

2. Concrete environmental impact: Concrete production generates a higher carbon footprint than asphalt due to its manufacturing process. However, concrete pavements are generally more reflective and lighter in color, reducing the urban heat island effect caused by heat absorption.

Noise Reduction Capabilities

Noise reduction can be an important consideration, particularly for projects located near residential areas or in regions with heavy traffic.

1. Asphalt noise reduction: Asphalt surfaces, especially those utilizing open-graded mixes, can reduce the noise generated by vehicles, benefiting local residents and businesses.

2. Concrete noise reduction: Concrete pavement can create higher noise levels compared to asphalt. However, advancements in concrete technology, such as incorporating rubberized materials and using “quiet pavement” designs, have helped mitigate this issue.

Climate Compatibility

The local climate in your area can impact the performance and longevity of your chosen pavement material, making climate compatibility another essential factor to consider.

1. Asphalt in varying climates: Asphalt’s flexibility makes it a prime choice for regions with extreme temperature fluctuations, as it can expand and contract without major damage. However, excessively hot climates may cause the surface to soften and deteriorate.

2. Concrete in varying climates: Concrete pavements are better suited for hot climates, resisting softening due to high temperatures. Conversely, the rigid nature of concrete makes it susceptible to cracking in areas with significant freeze-thaw cycles.

Roadway and Traffic Conditions

The intended use and traffic conditions of your paving project can heavily influence which pavement material is most appropriate.

1. Asphalt for roadways: Asphalt’s quick installation and ability to flex under heavy loads make it a popular choice for high-traffic areas and busy roads. The smooth surface provided by asphalt also offers a comfortable driving experience.

2. Concrete for roadways: While concrete may be a more costly option for high-traffic areas, it can be more suitable for specific situations, such as intersections or areas where heavy equipment is used. The rigidity of concrete helps resist rutting and deformation under intense pressure.


When deciding between asphalt and concrete for your residential or commercial paving project, several factors, including durability, costs, aesthetics, environmental impact, and local factors, must be weighed carefully to make the most suitable choice. Taking the time to consider these various aspects can ensure that the pavement material you select meets your unique requirements and offers long-lasting, high-performance results.

Partnering with a reputable paving contractor like Economy Asphalt can be invaluable in guiding you through this decision-making process. Our team of experts is dedicated to providing tailored services and insights to help you determine the best pavement material for your unique circumstances. Trust Economy Asphalt to help you make an informed and effective choice for your residential or commercial project, ensuring a successful and stunning pavement solution that serves your needs for years to come.

The experienced team at Economy Asphalt is here to help you make an informed decision regarding your pavement material. Contact us today to discuss your project’s unique needs, and let us provide you with expert guidance and our top-rated asphalt paving services, ensuring cost-effective and high-quality results tailored to your specific situation.

Posted in Asphalt Maintenance, Commercial Paving

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *